Skip to main content

Full text of "Joseph Zabara and His "Book of Delight""

See other formats


Early Journal Content on JSTOR, Free to Anyone in the World 

This article is one of nearly 500,000 scholarly works digitized and made freely available to everyone in 
the world by JSTOR. 

Known as the Early Journal Content, this set of works include research articles, news, letters, and other 
writings published in more than 200 of the oldest leading academic journals. The works date from the 
mid-seventeenth to the early twentieth centuries. 

We encourage people to read and share the Early Journal Content openly and to tell others that this 
resource exists. People may post this content online or redistribute in any way for non-commercial 

Read more about Early Journal Content at 
journal-content . 

JSTOR is a digital library of academic journals, books, and primary source objects. JSTOR helps people 
discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content through a powerful research and teaching 
platform, and preserves this content for future generations. JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit 
organization that also includes Ithaka S+R and Portico. For more information about JSTOR, please 

502 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 


Joseph Zabaea 1 has only in recent times received the 
consideration due to him as a poet. Yet his Book of 
Delight, finished about the year 1200, 2 is more tban a 
poetical romance. It is a golden link between folk- 
literature and imaginative poetry. The poem is of con- 
siderable length ; but while the framework is original, the 
stories and sayings, which are incidentally introduced, are 
compiled, not invented. Hence, to the folklorist, the poem 
is as valuable as to the literary critic. For though Zabara's 
compilation is similar to such well known models as the 
Book of Sindibad, the Kalilah Vedimnah, and others of the 
class, yet its appearance in Europe is half a century earlier 
than the translations by which those other products of the 
East became part of the popular literature of the Western 
world. Thus, at the least, the Book of Delight is an im- 
portant addition to the scanty store of the folk-lore records 
of the early part of the thirteenth century. 

As a poet and writer of Hebrew, Joseph Zabara's place 

1 The Constantinople edition spells the name n"lK3T, the Paris edition 
K"OT, Joseph Kimchi (Ozar Neehmad, I. 106), spells it in the former 
manner. See also HamazMr, viii. 89. But, for the whole question of 
Kimchi's supposed citation of Zabara, see Steinsohneider in Hamazhir, 
xiii. 106 and 113, especially the latter place, where much information 
will be found. On the identification of 13T with Zabara, see Sachs' 
Introduction to the Paris edition, and Steinschneider's Die Hebr. 

Uehersetz., pp. 441 and 989. Senior Sachs gives some reasons for holding 
that the poet's father was named Meir. 

2 I fix this date by a phrase used in the Constantinople edition. Here 
Sheshet Benveniste is described by Zabara as }pTD N*3Jn (the phrase is 
absent from the Paris edition). Sheshet Benveniste (G-raetz, Geschichte, 
VI. note 1) was born in 1131. He would thus not be seventy until 1201, 
and Zabara would hardly have used the term JpTfl unless Sheshet was 
turned seventy. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 503 

is equally significant. He was probably the first 1 to write 
Hebrew in rhymed prose, with interspersed snatches of 
verse, 2 the form invented by Arabian poets, and much 
esteemed as the medium for story-telling, and for writing 
social satire. The best and best-known specimens of this 
form of poetry in Hebrew, are Charizi's Taehkemoni, and 
his translation of Hariri. But, though Zabara has less art 
than Charizi, and far less technical skill, yet in him are all 
the qualities in the bud which Charizi's poems present in 
the full-blown flower. The reader of Zabara feels that 
other poets will develop his style and surpass him ; the 
reader of Charizi knows of a surety that in him the style 
has reached its climax. 

Of Joseph Zabara little is known beyond what may be 
gleaned from a discriminating study of the Book of Delight. 
That this romance is largely an autobiography in fact, just 
as it is in form, there can be no reasonable doubt. The 
poet writes with so much indignant warmth of the people 
of certain cities, of their manner of life, their morals and 
their culture, that one can only infer that he is relating his 
personal experiences. That Zabara, like the hero of his 
romance, travelled much during the latter portion of the 
twelfth century, is known from the researches of Geiger. 3 
He was born in Barcelona, and returned there to die. But 
in the interval, we find him an apt pupil of Joseph Kimchi, 
in Narbonne. Joseph Kimchi, the founder of the famous 
Kimchi family, carried to Provence the culture of Spain ; 

1 Mr. Joseph Jacobs, to whom I owe many valuable suggestions, has 
proved that Berachya Nakdan, who also wrote in rhymed prose, lived at 
the end of the twelfth century. It is thus doubtful whether to him 
or to Zabara belongs the distinction of introducing this form into Hebrew. 
It has been conjectured that Berachya visited Narbonne, where Zabara 
also studied under Joseph Kimchi. It is possible that the latter was the 
inventor of the style. 

2 I have not translated any of these poetical snatches (of which there 
are more in the Constantinople edition than in the Paris), as thei» literary 
merit is small. 

s Ozar Nechmad, I. p. 106, etc. 

K K 2 

504 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

and Joseph Zabara may have acquired from him his 
mastery over Hebrew which our poet writes with purity 
and admirable simplicity. 1 The difficulties presented in 
some passages of the Booh of Delight are entirely due 
to the corrupt state of the text. Joseph Kimchi, who 
flourished in Provence from 1150 to 1170, quotes Joseph 
Zabara twice, with approval, in explaining verses in 
Proverbs. It would thus seem that Joseph Zabara, in his 
student days, was already devoted to the proverb-lore on 
which he draws so lavishly in his maturer work. 

Dr. Steinschneider, to whom belongs the credit of re- 
discovering Zabara in modern times, 2 says that the poet 
was probably a physician. There is more than probability 
in the case ; there is certainty. The romance is built by a 
doctor : there is more talk of medicine in it than of any 
other topic of discussion. Moreover the author, who denies 
that he is much of a Talmudist, accepts the compliment 
paid to him by his visitor, Enan, that he is " skilled and 
well-informed in the science of medicine." 3 There is, too, 
a professional tone about many of the quips and gibes in 
which Zabara indulges concerning doctors. "A philoso- 
pher," says Zabara, " was sick unto death, and his doctor 
gave him up ; yet the patient recovered. The convalescent 
was walking in the street when the doctor met him. 
'You come,' said he, 'from the other world.' 'Yes,' 
rejoined the patient, ' I come from there, and I saw 
there the awful retribution that falls on the doctors ; 
for they kill their patients. Yet do not feel alarmed. You 

1 Some of Zabara's phrases are a little strange, and possibly suggest 
that the author was translating from a non-Semitic language. But the 
linguistic evidence for this is very slight, and I should be disinclined to 
base any argument on it. The phrases are just as probably Greek as 
Romance, and Zabara may have been using an Arabic translation of a 
Greek text. On the other hand, some of the words used strengthen the 
argument in favour of the theory that Zabara may have had a Romance 
text before him when compiling some of his stories. 

2 Ersch unci Griiber, ii. 31, article "Joseph Zabara." 
:t Paris edition, p. 31. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 505 

will not suffer. I told them on my oath that you are no 
doctor.' ' n Again, in one of the poetical interludes (found 
only in the Constantinople edition) occurs this very pro- 
fessional sneer : — " A doctor and the Angel of Death both 
kill, but the former charges a fee." Who but a doctor 
would enter into a scathing denunciation of the current 
diagnosis, which Zabara does in a sarcastic passage which 
Erter must unconsciously have imitated ? And if further 
proof be needed that Zabara was a man of science, the 
evidence is forthcoming ; for Zabara several times appeals 
to experiment in proof of his assertions. 2 

The life of Joseph ben Meir Zabara 3 was apparently 
not a happy one. He left Barcelona in search of learning 
and comfort ; he found the former, but the latter eluded 
him. It is hard to say from the Book of Delight whether 
he was a woman-hater or not. On the one hand he says 
many pretty things about women, and the moral of the 
first section of the romance is : Put your trust in women ; 
while the moral of the second section of the poem is : A 
good woman is the best part of man. But, though this 
is so, Zabara does undoubtedly quote a large number 
of stories, full of point and sting — stories which tell of 
women's wickedness and infidelity, of their weakness of 
intellect and fickleness of will. His philogynist tags 
hardly compensate for his misogynist satires. He runs 
with the hare and hunts with the hounds. But Oriental 
satire directed against women must not be taken too 
seriously. As Gudemann has shown, the very Jews who 
wrote most bitterly of women were loud in praises of their 
own wives — the women whom alone they knew intimately. 
Woman was the standing butt for men to hurl their darts 
at, and one cannot help feeling that a good deal of the fun 

1 Paris edition, p. 24. 

2 Ibid., p. 32. In the Constantinople edition there are two other 
instances of experimental proofs. 

s Senior Sachs argues with plausibility in favour of the supposition 
that Zabara's father was named Meir. 

506 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

got its point from the knowledge that the charges were 
exaggerated or untrue. You find the Jewish satirists 
exhausting all their stores of drollery over the subject of 
rollicking drunkenness. They roar till their sides creak 
over the humour of the wine-bibber. They laugh at him 
and with bim. They turn again and again to the subject, 
which with the Jewish poets shares the empire with 
women. Yet we know well enough that the writers of 
these Hebrew Anacreontic lyrics were sober men, who 
rarely indulged in over-much strong drink. In short, the 
mediaeval Jewish satirists were gifted with much of what 
is now foolishly styled the " new humour." Joseph Zabara 
was a new humourist. He has the quaint subtlety of the 
author of the Ingoldsby Legends, and the exaggeration of 
trifles which is the stock-in-trade of the Anglo-American 
school of modern funny men. Woman plays with him the 
part that the mother-in-law played with the latter a 
generation ago. In Zabara, again, there is a good deal of 
mere rudeness, which the author seems to mistake for 
cutting repartee. This, I take it, is another characteristic 
of the so-called new humour. 

The probable explanation of the marked divergence 
between Zabara's stories and the moral he draws from 
them lies, however, a little deeper. The stories themselves 
are probably Indian in origin ; hence they are marked by 
the tone hostile to woman so characteristic of Indian folk 
lore. On the other hand, if Zabara himself was a friendly 
critic of woman, his own moralisings in her favour are 
explained. This theory is by no means upset by the fact 
mentioned below, 1 for those stories, too, are translations, 
and Zabara cannot be held responsible for their contents. 
The selection in his day must have been restricted within 
very narrow limits. 

Zabara's reading must have been extensive. He knew 
something of astronomy, philosophy, the science of physio- 

1 See page 510. 

Joseph Zabara and his "Book of Delight." 507 

gnomy, 1 music, mathematics and physics, and a good deal 
of medicine. He was familiar with Arabian collections of 
proverbs and tales, for he several times informs his readers 
that he was drawing on Arabic sources. He knew the 
Choice of Pearls, the Midrashic Stories of King Solomon, the 
Maxims of the Philosophers, the Proverbs of the Wise ; but not 
Sendabar in its Hebrew form. 2 His acquaintance with the 
language of the Bible was thorough ; but he makes one or 
two blunders in quoting the substance of Scriptural 
passages. Though he disclaimed the title of a Tal- 
mudical scholar, he was not ignorant of the Rabbinical 
literature. Everyone quotes it : the fox, the woman, 
Enan, and the author. He was sufficiently at home 
in this literature to pun therein. He also knew the 
story of Tobit, but as he introduces it as " a most 
marvellous tale " it is clear that this book of the 
Apocrypha was not widely popular in his day. The story, 
as Zabara tells it, differs considerably from the Apocryphal 
version of it. The incidents are misplaced, the story of 
the betrothal is disconnected with that of the recovery of 
the money by Tobit, the incident of the gallows occurs in 
no other known text of the story. In one point, Zabara's 
version strikingly agrees with the Hebrew and Chaldee 
texts of Tobit as against the Greek ; Tobit's son is not 
accompanied by a dog on his journey to recover his 
father's long-lost treasure. 

One of the tales told by Zabara seems to imply a phe- 
nomenon of the existence of which there is no other 
evidence. There seem to have been in Spain a small class 

1 In the Constantinople edition there is, near the beginning, a long 
passage (absent from the Paris edition), concerning the relations between 
a man's bodily peculiarities, such as his stature and so forth, and his 
character. There was in particular a prejudice against men of exceptional 
height ; they were regarded as mostly fools. (Cf. i"P21D nK'yD, I. 4.) 

2 Zabara does not seem to have known Adelard's Questions. Only two 
of them (Nos. 32 and 51) occur in the long string of queries and answers 
which figure in the Booh of Delight. 

508 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

of Jews who were secret converts to Christianity. They 
passed openly for Jews, but were in truth Christiana. The 
motive for the concealment is unexplained. 1 

It remains for me to describe the texts now extant of the 
Booh of Delight. In 1865 the Sefer Shaashuim appeared, 
from a fifteenth century MS. in Paris, in the second 
volume of a Hebrew periodical called the Lebanon. In 
the following year the late Senior Sachs wrote an intro- 
duction to it, and to two other publications, which were 
afterwards issued together under the title Yen Lebanon, 
Paris, 1866. The editor was aware of the existence of 
another text, but, strange to tell, he did not take the trouble 
to examine it. Had he done this, his own edition would 
have been greatly improved. For the Bodleian Library 
possesses another copy of the Book of Delight, undated 
and without place of issue, but printed in Constantinople 
in 1577. The editor was Isaac Akrish, as we gather from a 
marginal note to the version of Tobit given by Joseph 
Zabara. This Isaac Akrish was a travelling bookseller, 
who printed interesting little books, and hawked them 
about. Dr. Steinschneider points out 2 that the date of 
Isaac Akrish's edition can be approximately fixed by the 
type. The type is that of the Jaabez press, established in 
Constantinople and Salonichi in 1560. This Constantinople 
edition is not only fuller than the Paris, it is, on the whole, 
more accurate. It is a good deal longer than the Paris 
edition, and the chief additions will be indicated in the 
notes below. The verbal variations between the two 
editions are extremely numerous, but the greater accu- 
racy of the Constantinople edition shows itself in many 

1 See the story, page 524 below. If the story was taken straight from 
an Arabic source, the introduction of the crucifix is explained. The story 
may have been originally about the Druses, or Nestorian Christians ; but, 
if so, it would be strange that Zabara should not have seen the inappro- 
priateness of the tale for Jewish readers. I am inclined to think that 
Zabara was aiming a blow at some section of the Barcelonian Jews. 

2 JSrsch und Gruber, ii. 28, p. 39; andii. 31, p. 93. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 509 

ways. The rhymes are much better preserved, though 
the Paris edition is occasionally superior in this re- 
spect. But many passages in the Paris edition which are 
quite unintelligible, are clear enough in the Constanti- 
nople edition. One or two instances will suffice to prove 
this. On p. 14 P. reads: rasb m^nn vwrai -ipm aipsi 
'n VW\n nnroi m« THEN, which is nonsense. C. reads 
"liann for msian, which at once restores the meaning. 
Near the end of page 36, P. reads : "O anBn bwo ins"''! 
V~in bv I3"«»bi wth naa^i • y-rip varw -ininn issn. 
The word natt?^ is unintelligible, but C. reads "03JOBP1, which 
is quite easy. Worst of all is the reading in P. of the name 
of the gigantic visitor, Enan. P. calls him win p, while O, 
rightly, gives his name as l&in p, which, inverted, makes 
Tl»n p. It is strange that Sachs, in his preface, gives the 
name correctly, while in the text itself the name is wrongly 
printed. Again, C. is better in calling the hero of the story 
given on page 520, below, pa, while P. calls him ]tn. So, in 
another # story, C. has "THD, while P. has •»D"iQ; the latter 
reading destroys the relevancy of the pointed reference in 
the tale to tilling the ground. O, again, is better in having 
ffip for *)12, and in several places the sense of a passage 
is lost in P. through its omissions. A striking example 
may be seen in P., page 36, where Enan's anger is quite 
unjustifiable ; but in C. the hero Joseph has several lines 
of violent abuse of Enan. That P. has been edited, is clear 
from one or two minor points. Thus in the story of the 
singer, C. describes the tree as naaNTO, or orange ; the word 
does not appear in P. Again, the Paris edition omits a 
passage in the description of Enan's friend, which might 
have been thought defamatory of Christianity. 1 The last 
lines of P. imply that the copy was made at a time of 
trouble; and the absence of rhyme itself throws suspicion 
on the genuineness of the passage: laV^ vama 'n 
pw )is~i tt» pi bvnar* yav nnsb *n "lawi nnsn nutbna. 

> ^rn jnns Kin »a 'fa b"k bib vnaai away non inon px 

510 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

There was nothing in the condition of the Jews of Bar- 
celona in 1200 to call for this sentiment. C. closes, more 
appropriately, thus : * nntwrt 02 noarb "WOr mpan 

arc * wis 02 tapbn sa?^ ♦ unw ma lapsa mam 
)B« ? VTon. 

In the Constantinople edition, the Sefer Shaashuim is 
preceded by three other items, (a) D^NDynn nasa ; (b) ma 
naabN ; (c) nt»S WO lasa. These, according to Stein- 
schneider (and from a careful perusal of them I am inclined 
to agree with him), are also by Joseph Zabara. 1 They 
belong, I think, to the Boole of Delight itself, and ought 
to be inserted in the " Leopard " section, as they 
are tales with strong bias against women. I should say 
that the copy of this edition, possessed by the Bodleian, is 
unique, no other copy is extant. Leopold Dukes had it 
copied some thirty years ago, but he appears to have made 
no use of his copy. 2 My own copy was made for me in 
1887 by Mr. Spero. 3 

The gigantic visitor of Joseph, the narrator, and un- 
doubtedly the author himself, is a strange being. Like 
the guide of Gil Bias on his adventures, he is called 
a demon, and he glares and emits smoke and fire. But 
he proves amenable to argument, and quotes the story 
of the washerwoman to show how it was that he became 
a reformed devil. This devil quotes the Rabbis, and is 
easily convinced that it is unwise for him to wed an 
ignorant bride. It would seem as though Zabara were, on 
the one hand, hurling a covert attack against some one 

1 See particularly Die Hebr. Uebersetz., p. 658. 

2 He often refers to the Sefer Shaashuim, quoting the Paris edition 
e.g., in his PhilosopJiisches aus dew Zehnten Jahrlmndert, p. 109. The 
poem is also quoted in the D"n "llpO to im^J?M '2 and end of ^ nW 'B 
in mien mm, p. 125. See also Steinschneider, JUn p T\\X\Yi, 'p. 7, 
and p^nn, VIII., p. 149, note 2 ; Dukes' Orient, 1850, pp. 250 and 299. 

s Mr. S. Scheohter and I hare long intended to re-edit the Booh of 
Delight. I am indebted to Mr. Schechter for much valuable help in 
writing this essay. Professor Kauf mann is about to edit the book. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 511 

who had advised him to leave Barcelona to his own 
hurt, while, on the other hand, satirising the eurrrent 
beliefs of Jews and Christians in evil spirits. More than 
one passage, as we have already seen, is decidedly anti- 
Christian, and I should not be surprised if the framework 
of the romance was polemical in intention. Certainly the 
framework is fresher and more elaborate than one would 
expect in a mere imitation. 

In the summary of the book which follows, I have only 
in one case (see page 522 below) attempted to reproduce 
the rhymed prose of the original Hebrew. This form of 
poetry is unsuited to the English language, and is indis- 
tinguishable from doggrel. I have not translated at full 
length, but I have endeavoured to reproduce Zabara 
accurately without introducing thoughts foreign to him. 

I offer no elaborate theory on the folk-lore of the poem. 
I shall be greatly mistaken, however, if the collection of 
stories that follow does not prove of considerable interest 
to those engaged in the tracking of fables to their native 
lairs. Here, in Zabara, we have an earlier instance than was 
previously known in Europe of an intertwined series of 
fables and witticisms, partly Indian, partly Greek in origin, 
welded together by the Hebrew poet by means of a frame- 
work. The use of the framework by a writer in Europe 
in the year 1200 is itself noteworthy. But Mr. Joseph 
Jacobs, who has already proved of much service to me, has 
promised to deal with this part of the subject at no very 
distant date. 

The Giant Guest. 

Once on a night, I, Joseph, lay upon my bed, and my sleep was 

sweet upon me, my one return for all my toil. Things there are 

which weary the soul and rest the body, others that weary the body 

and rest the soul, but sleep brings calm to the body and the soul at 

once While I slept, I dreamt ; and a gigantic but manlike 

figure appeared before me, rousing me from my slumber. " Arise, 
thou sleeper, rouse thyself and see the wine while it is red ; come sit 
thee down and eat of what I provide." It was dawn as I hastily rose, 
and I saw before me wine, bread and viands ; and in the man's hand 

512 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

was a lighted lamp, -which cast a glare into every corner. I answered 
and said, " What are these, my master.'' " My wine, my bread, my 
viands ; come eat and drink with me, for I love thee as one of my 
mother's sons.'' And I thanked him, but protested : "I cannot eat or 
drink till I have prayed to the Orderer of all my ways ; for Moses, the 
choice of the prophets and the head of those called, ordained ' Eat not 
with the blood,' therefore no son of Israel will eat until he prays for 
his soul, for the blood is the soul. . . ." ' 

Then said he, " Pray, if such be thy wish "; and I bathed my hands 
and face and prayed. Then I ate of all that was before me, for my 
soul loved him. . . . Wine I would not drink, though he pressed me 
sore. " Wine," I said, " blindeth the eyes, robbeth the old of wisdom 
and the body of strength, it revealeth the secrets of friends, and 
raiseth discussion between brothers.'' The man's anger was roused. 
"Why blasphemest thou against wine, and bearest false witness 
against it ? Wine bringeth joy ; sorrow and sighing fly before it. 
It strengtheneth the body, maketh the heart generous, prolongeth 
pleasure, and deferreth age ; faces it maketh shine, and the senses 
it maketh bright." 

" Agreed, but let thy servant take the water first as the ancient 
physicians advise, later I will take the wine, a little, without water." 

When I had eaten and drunk with him, I asked him for his name 
and his purpose. " I come," said he, " from a distant land, from 
pleasant and fruitful hills, my wisdom is as thine, my law as thine, 
my name Enan Hanatash, the son of Arnan Hadash." I was amazed 
at the name, unlike any I had ever heard before. " Come with me 
from this land, and I will tell thee all my secret lore ; leave this spot, 
for they know not here thy worth and thy wisdom. I will take thee 
to another place, pleasant as a garden, peopled by loving men, wise 
above all others." But I answered, " My lord, I cannot go. Here 
are many wise and friendly; while I live they give me life, when I die 
they will make sweet my death. . . . I fear thee for thy long limbs, 
and in thy face I see clear-cut the marks of un worthiness ; 2 1 fear thee, 
and will not be thy companion lest there befall me what befell the 
leopard with the fox." And I told him the story. 

The Fox and the Leopard. 
A leopard 3 once lived in content and plenty ; ever he found easy 
sustenance for his wife and his children. Hard by there dwelt his 

1 Berachoth, 10J. 

* In C. there here occurs the long passage mentioned on page 507. Note 1 

3 On the leopard or panther in folk-lore, see Paulus Cassel, MiscMe 
Sindbad, pp. 214-217. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 513 

neighbour and friend, the fox. The fox felt in his heart that his life 
was safe only so long as the leopard could catch other prey; and 
planned out a method for ridding himself of this dangerous friendship. 
Before the evil cometh, say the wise, counsel is good. " Let me move 
him hence," thought the fox ; " I will lead him to the paths of death ; 
for the sages say : ' If one come to slay thee, be beforehand with him, 
and slay him instead.' " Next day the fox went to the leopard and 
told him of a spot he had seen, a spot of gardens and lilies, where 
fawns and does disported themselves, and everything was fair. The 
leopard went with him to behold this paradise, and rejoiced with 
exceeding joy. "Ah," thought the fox, "many a smile ends in a 
tear." But the leopard was charmed, and wished to move to this de- 
lightful abode ; " but, first," said he, 'I will go to consult my wife, my 
life-long comrade, the bride of my youth." The fox was sadly afraid- 
Full well he knew the wisdom and the craft of the leopard's wife. 
" Nay," said he, " trust not thy wife. A woman's counsel is evil and 
foolish, her heart hard like marble ; she is a plague in a house. Yes, 
ask her advice, and do the opposite." 1 .... The leopard told his wife 
that he was resolved to go. " Beware of the fox," she exclaimed, 
" two small animals there are, the craftiest they, by far : the serpent 
and the fox. Hast thou not heard how the fox bound the lion, and 
sle w him with cunniDg ? " " How did the fox dare," asked the leopard, 
" to come near enough to the lion to do it ? " 

The Fox and the Lion. 

Then said the leopard's wife : — The lion loved the fox, but the fox 
had no faith in him, and plotted his death. One day the fox went to 
the lion whining that a pain had seized him in the head. " I have 
heard," said the fox, " that physicians prescribe for a head-ache that 
the patient shall be tied up hand and foot." The lion assented, and 
bound up the fox with a cord. "Ah," blithely said the fox, "my 
pain is gone." Time passed, and the lion's turn came to suffer in his 
head. In sore distress he went to the fox, and exclaimed : — " Bind 
me up, that I too may be healed as happened with thee." The fox 
took fresh cords and bound the lion up. Then went he to fetch great 
stones which he cast on the lion's head and thus crushed him. "There- 
fore, my dear leopard," concluded his wife, " trust not the fox, for I 
fear him and his wiles." 

The leopard would not hearken to his wife's advice, yet 

1 The malice and craft of women are the favourite theme of Indian 
stories. Cf. the series in Sindibad. 

514 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

was he somewhat moved by her warning, and he told the 
fox of his misgiving. " Ah," replied the fox, " I fear your 
fate will be like the goldsmith's ; let me tell you his story, 
and you will know how silly it is to listen to a wife's 

The Goldsmith who followed his Wife's Counsel. 
A goldsmith of Babylon, skilful in his craft, was one day at work. 
"Listen to me," said his wife, "and I will make thee rich and 
honoured. Our lord, the king, has an only daughter, and he loves 
her as his life. Fashion for her a golden image of herself, and I will 
bear it to her as a gift." The statue was soon made, and the princess 
rejoiced at seeing it. She gave the artist's wife a cloak and earrings, 
and she showed them to her husband in triumph. " Bat where is 
the wealth and the honour?" he asked ; " the statue was worth much 
more than you have brought.'' Next day the king saw the statue in 
his daughter's hand, and his anger was kindled. " Is it not ordered,' 
he cried, " that none should make an image ? Cut off his right 
hand." The king's command was carried out, and daily the smith 
wept, and exclaimed : " Take warning from me, ye husband? , and 
obey not the voice of your wives." 

The Woodcutter and the Woman. 
The leopard shuddered when he heard this tale ; but the fox went 
on : A hewer of wood in Damascus was cutting logs, and his wife sat 
spinning by his side. " My departed father," she said, " was a better 
workman than thou. He could chop with both hands : when the right 
hand was tired he used the left.'' "Nay," said he, " no woodcutter 
does that." "Ah, my dear," she entreated, " try and do it as my father 
did." The witless wight raised his left hand to hew the wood, but 
struck his right-hand thumb instead. Without a word he seized the 
axe and smote her on the head, and she died. His deed was noised 
about ; the woodcutter was seized and stoned for his crime. " There- 
fore," continued the fox, " I say unto thee, all women are deceivers 
and trappers of souls." 

Man's Love and Woman's.' 

Let me tell you more of theBO wily stratagems, said the fox. A 
king of the Arabs, wise and well-advised, was one day seated with his 
councillors, who were loud in the praise of women, lauding their 

1 Cf, Jellinek, Beth. Hamidrash iv. 147. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 515 

virtues and their wisdom. " Cease these words," said the king. 
"Never since the world began has there has been a good woman. 
They love for their own ends." " But," pleaded his sages, " king, 
thou art hasty. Women there are, wise and faithful, who love their 
husbands and tend their children." " Then," said the king, " here is 
my city before you : search it through, and find one of the good 
women of whom you speak." They sought, and they found a 
woman, chaste and wise, fair as the moon and bright as the 
sun, the wife of a wealthy trader ; and the councillors reported 
about her to the king. He sent for her husband, and received him 
with favour. "I have something for thy ear," said the king. 
" I have a good and precious daughter : I will not give her to 
a king or a prince : let me find a simple, faithful man, who will 
love her and hold her in esteem. Thou art such a one ; thou shalt 
have her. But thou art married : slay thy wife to-night, and to- 
morrow thou shalt wed my daughter." " I am unworthy," pleaded 
the man, " to be the shepherd of thy flock, much less the husband of 
thy daughter." But the king would take no denial. " But how shall 
I kill my wife ? For five and twenty years she has eaten of my bread 
and drunk of my cup. She is the joy of my heart ; her love and 
esteem grow day by day." " Slay her," said the king, " and be king 
hereafter." He went forth from the presence, downcast and sad, 
thinking over, and a little shaken by, the king's temptation. At home 
he saw his wife and his two babes. " Better," he cried, " is my wife 
than a kingdom. Cursed be all kings who tempt men to sip sorrow, 
calling it joy.'' The king waited his coming in vain ; but when he 
found that the man's love had conquered his lust, said, with a sneer, 
" Thou art no man : thy heart is a woman's." In the evening the king 
summoned the woman secretly. She came, and the king praised her 
beauty and her wisdom. His heart was burning with love for her, but 
he could not wed another man's wife. " Slay thy husband to-night, 
and to-morrow be my queen." With a smile, the woman consented ; 
and the king gave her a sword made of tin, for he knew the weak 
mind of woman. " Strike once," he said to her ; " the sword is 
sharp ; you need not essay a second blow." She gave her husband a 
choice repast, and wine to make him drunk. As he lay asleep, she 
grasped the sword and struck him on the head ; and the tin bent, 
and he awoke. With some ado she quieted him, aud he fell asleep 
again. Next morning the king asked her, had she obeyed his orders : 
" Yes," said she ; " but thou didst frustrate thine own counsel." Then 
the king assembled his sages, and bade her tell all that she had 
attempted ; and the husband, too, was fetched, to tell his story. " Did 
I not tell you to cease your praises of women ? '' asked the king, 

516 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

In Dispraise op Woman. 

The fox follows up these effective narratives with a 
lengthy string of well-worn quotations against women, of 
which the following are a few : " Socrates, the wise and 
saintly, hated them and loathed their forms. His wife was 
thin and short. They asked him, How could a man like 
you choose such a woman for your wife ? "I chose," said 
Socrates, " of the evil the least possible amount." Once 
he was walking by the way and saw a woman hanging 
from a fig-tree. " Would," said Socrates, "that all the fruit 
were like this." A noble built a new house, and wrote 
over the door " Let nothing evil pass this way." — " Then 
how does his wife go in ? " asked Diogenes. 1 " Your enemy 
is dead," said one to another. " I would rather hear that 
he had got married " was the reply. 

So much, said the fox to the leopard, I have told thee 
that thou mayest know how little women are to be 
trusted. They deceive men in life and betray them in 
death. " But," queried the leopard, " what could my wife 
do to harm me after I am dead ?" " Listen," rejoined 
the fox, " and I will tell thee of a deed viler than any that 
I have narrated already." 

The Widow and her Husband's Corpse.* 

The kings of Rome, when they hanged a man, denied him burial 
until the tenth day. That the friends and relatives of the victim 
might not steal the body, an officer of high rank was set to watch 
the tree by nights. Were the body stolen, the officer was hung up 

1 Cf D*D3n •hem, 69 and 70. 

J For parallels, see Mr Joseph Jacobs, Fables of Aesop, VoL I., page 245. 
Of. Tosafoth to Kiddushin, fol. 805, which Mr. Clouston (page 340 of his 
edition of Sindibad") confuses with the Talmud itself. In the parallels 
there is considerable variation as to the ruses of the widow to assimilate 
her husband's body to that of the criminal. In the Liber de Bonis there 
is no mutilation at all. See also Steinschneider, Hamaxhir, xiii. 78. Sir 
Walter Scott uses part of this incident in the standard-watching episode 
in The Talisman. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight," 517 

in its place. A knight of high degree once rebelled against the king, 
and he was hanged on a tree. The officer on guard was startled 
at midnight to hear a piercing shriek of anguish from a little 
distance ; and he turned aside towards the voice to discover the 
meaning. He came to an open grave where the common people 
were buried, and saw a weeping woman loud in laments for her 
departed spouse. He sent her home with words of comfort. Next 
night the same scene was repeated, and as the officer spoke his gentle 
soothings to her, a love for him wa3 born in her heart, and her dead 
husband was forgotten. And as they spoke words of love they 
neared the tree, and lo ! the body which the officer was set to watch 
was gone. " Begone," he said, " and I will fly, or my life must pay 
the penalty of my dalliance." " not, my lord," she said, " we can 
raise my husband from his grave and hang him instead of the stolen 
corpse. " " But I fear the prince of death. I cannot drag a man from 
his grave." " I alone will do it then," said the woman ; " I will dig 
him out." " Alas ! " cried the officer, when she had done the fear- 
some deed : " the corpse I watched was bald, your husband has thick 
hair ; the change will be detected." " Nay," said the woman, " I will 
make him bald," and she tore his hair out, with execrations, and 
they hung him on the tree. But few days passed and the pair were 

The Leopard's Fate. 

The leopard trembled at this tale. Angrily he ad- 
dressed his wife : " Come, get up and follow me, or I will 
slay thee." Together they went with their young ones, 
and the fox was their guide, and they reached the pro- 
mised place, and encamped by the waters. Seven days 
were gone, when the rains descended, and in the deep of 
the night the river rose and engulphed the leopard family 
in their beds. " Woe is me," sighed the leopard, " that I 
did not listen to my wife." And he died before his 

The Journey Begun by Joseph and Enan. 

The author has now finished his protest against his 
visitor Enan's design to make him join him on a roving 
expedition. Enan glares, and asks, " Am I a fox and thou 
a leopard that I should fear thee ? " Then his note 


518 The Jewish Quarterly Renew. 

changes, and his tone becomes coaxing and bland. Joseph 
cannot resist his fascination. Together they start, riding 
on their asses. Then said Enan unto Joseph, " Carry thou 
me, or I will carry thee." But, continues the narrator, 
Joseph, we were both riding on our asses. " What dost 
thou mean ? Our asses carry us both. Explain thy words." 
" It is the story of the peasant 1 with the king's officer." 

The Cletek Girl and the King's Dream. 8 

A king with many wives dreamt that he saw a monkey' leaping 
over them ; his face fell, and his spirit was troubled. " This is none 
other," said he, " than a foreign king, who will invade my realm, and 
take my harem for his spoil." An officer told the king of a clever 
interpreter of dreams, and the king despatched him to find out the 
meaning of his ominous vision. 4 He set forth on his ass, and met a 
countryman riding : " Carry me," said the officer, " or I will carry 
thee." The peasant was amazed : " But our asses carry us both," he 
said. And as they pass on the officer made remarks on the field and 
the tower. " Thou tiller of the earth," said the officer, " thou art 
earth, and eateth earth." "There is snow on the hill," said the 
officer, and as the month was Tammuz, the peasant laughed. 
They passed a road with wheat growing on each side. " A horse, 
blind in one eye, has passed here," said the officer, " loaded with oil 
one side, and vinegar on the other." 5 They saw a field richly covered 
with abounding corn, and the peasant praised it. " Yes," said the 
officer, " if the corn is not already eaten." They saw a lofty tower. 
"Well fortified," remarked the peasant. "Fortified without, if not 
ruined within," replied the officer. A funeral passed them. " As to 
this old man whom they are burying," said the officer, "I cannot 
tell whether he is alive or dead." And the peasant thought his com- 
panion mad to make such unintelligible remarks. They neared a 

1 C, *T , 1D ; P., 'DIB. This confusion I have noted in varying forms of 
other Midrashim. 

2 See the essay Die Kluge Dime, in Benfey's Kleinere Schrifter, Part 
III. page 156 ; Jacobs' Indian Fairy Tales, p. 251. 

•a, spP;P.,*l". 

4 C. is here much more intelligible than P., which does not introduce 
the peasant, but we suddenly find him conversing with the officer. So, 
later on, the series of enigmatic remarks by the officer is very confused 
in P. 

5 See Echa Rabbathi I., in the seventh Athenian episode. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 519 

village where the peasant lived, and he invited the officer to stay with 
him overnight. The peasant, in dead of the night, told his wife 
and daughters of the foolish things the officer had said, though he 
looked quite wise. " Nay," said the peasant's youngest daughter, a 
maiden of fifteen years, " the man is no fool ; thou didst not com- 
prehend the depth of his meaning. The tiller of the earth eats food 
grown from the earth. ' The snow on the hill ' meant thy white 
beard (on thy head) ; thou should'st have answered, ' Time caused it.' ' 
The horse blind in one eye he knew had passed, because he saw that 
the wheat was eaten on one side of the way, and not on the other ; and 
as for its burden, he saw that the vinegar had parched the dust, while 
the oil had not. His saying, ' Carry me, or I will carry thee,' signifies 
that he who beguiles the way with stories and proverbs and riddles, 
carries his companion, relieving him from the tedium of the journey. 
The corn of the field they passed," continued the girl, " was already 
eaten if the owner were poor, and had sold it before it was reaped. 
The lofty and stately tower was in ruins within if it was without 
necessary stores. About the funeral, too, his remark was true. If 
the old man. left a son he was still alive, if he were childless, he was 
indeed dead." 

In the morning, the girl asked her father to give the officer the 
foodshe would prepare. 1 She gave him thirty eggs, a dish full of milk, 
and a whole loaf. " Tell me," said she, " how many days old the 
month is ; is the moon new, and the sun at it? zenith ? " Her father 
ate two eggs, a little of the loaf, and drank some of the milk, and 
gave the rest to the officer. " Tell thy daughter," he said, " the sun 
is not full, neither is the moon, for the month is two days old." " Ah," 
laughed the peasant, as he told his daughter the answers of the officer, 
" ah, my girl, I told you he was a fool, for we are now in the middle 
of the month." " Did you eat anything of what I gave you ? " 
asked the girl of her father. And he told her of the two eggs, the 
morsel of bread, and the sip of water that he had taken. " Now I 
know," said the girl, " of a surely that the man is very wise." And 
the officer, too, felt that she was wise, and so he told her the king's 
dream. She went back with him to the king. " Search thy harem," 
said the girl, " and thou wilt find among thy women a man disguised 
in female garb." 3 He searched, and found that her words were true 

1 nD~IJ JDtn. C. alone has this pun. 

1 The whole of this part of the story is absent from P. 

3 The incident of a man disguised as a woman occurs, though in another 
context, in the seventh Vizir's story in Sindibad. See Clouston, page 286, 
and Cassel, page 11a of Hebrew text, and page 154 for comments and 

LL 2 

520 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

The man was slain, and the women too, and the peasant's daughter 
became the king's sole queen, for he never took another wife besides 

The Night's Rest. 

Thus Joseph and the giant Enan journey on, and they 
stay over-night in a village inn. Then commences a series 
of semi-medical wrangles which fill up a large portion of 
the book. Joseph demands food and wine, and Enan gives 
him a little of the former and none of the latter. Even 
their asses are starved, and Joseph sarcastically remarks : 
" To-morrow it will be indeed a case of carry thou me or 
I thee, for our asses will not be able to bear us." At dawn 
Enan rouses him, and when he sees that his ass is still 
alive, he exclaims, " Man and beast thou savest, O Lord ! " l 

They proceed, and Enan weeps as they near a town. 
Here, says he, my dear friend died, a man of wisdom and 
of judgment. I will tell thee a little of his cleverness. 

The Dishonest Singer' and the "Wedding Robes. 
A man once came crying to him in distress. His only daughter 
was betrothed to a youth, and the bridegroom and his father came to 
the bride's house on the eve of the wedding to view her ornaments 
and beautiful clothes. When the bride's father rose next day, every- 
thing had vanished, jewels and trousseau together. " My friend," said 
Enan, " went back with the man to examine the scene of the robbery. 
He found but one place in the wall where entry was possible, a crevice 
in which an orange tree grew, and its position acted like thorns and 
prickles. Next door lived a singer, Paltiel ben Agan 3 by name, and 
my late friend, the judge, interviewed him and made him strip. His 
body was covered with cuts and scratches, and his guilt discovered. 
" My son,'' said he, 4 " beware of singers, for they are mostly thieves ; 
trust no word of theirs, for they are liars ; they are fond of women, 
and long after other people's money. They fancy they are clever, 
but they know not their left hand from their right ; they raise their 
hands all day and call, but know not to whom. A singer stands at 
his post, raised above all other men, and he thinks he is as lofty as 
his place. He constantly emits sounds which mount to his brain and 
dry it up ; hence he is so witless.'' 

• See p. 509 above. ' P. reads Jtn, C, |M. 3 P., has pJJ. 

6 All of this diatribe occurs only in 0. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 521 

The Nobleman and the Necklace. 

Then Enan told me another story of his friend the judge's sagacity : 
A man lived in Cordova, Jacob by name, the Broker. Once a 
jewelled necklet was entrusted to him for sale by the judge, the 
owner demanding 500 pieces of gold as its price. Jacob had the chain 
in his hand when he met a nobleman, one of the king's intimate 
friends. The nobleman offered 400 pieces for the necklet, which 
Jacob refused. " Come with me to my house," said the would-be 
purchaser. The Jew accompanied him home, and the nobleman 
went within. Jacob waited till the evening, but no one came out. 
The nobleman denied all knowledge of the jewels, so Jacob went to 
the judge. He sent for the nobles to address them as was his wont, 
and he said to his servant, " Take the fraudulent nobleman's shoe and 
go to his wife. Show the shoe and say : Your lord bids me ask you 
for the necklace he bought yesterday." The wife gave the servant 
the ornament, and it was restored to its rightful owner. 

The Son and the Slave. 1 

And Enan went on : A merchant of wealth Untold, had an only 
son who when he grew up said : " Father, send me on a voyage, that I 
may trade and see foreign lands, and talk with men of wisdom to 
learn from their words." The father purchased a ship and sent him on 
a voyage with much wealth and many friends. The father was left 
at home with his slave in whom he put his trust. Suddenly a pain 
seized him in the heart, and he died without directing how his 
property was to be divided. The slave took possession of everything ; 
no one in the town knew whether he was the man's son or not. Ten 
years passed, and the real son returned, with his ship laden with 
wealth. As they neared the harbour, the ship was nearly wrecked. 
They cast everything overboard, but in vain ; the crew were all thrown 
into the sea. The son reached the shore destitute, and returned to his 
father's house ; but the slave drove him away, denying his identity. 
They went before the judge. " Find the merchant's grave," he said to 
the slave, " and bring me the dead man's bones. I shall burn them for 
his neglect to leave a will, thus rousing strife as to his property." 
The slave started to obey, but the son stayed him. ' Keep all," said 
he, " but disturb not my father's bones." " Thou art the son,'' said 
the judge ; " take this other as thy life-long slave." 

1 Cf. Jellinek IV. 146 ; but the close of the story is different. See also 
pcnn lytJ', ll, where there is a similar tale ; but the end differs from both 
versions. The king takes two separate bones for the test of blood 

522 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

Joseph and Enan pass to the the city of Tobiah. 1 At 
the gate they are accosted by an old and venerable man, to 
whom they explain that for seven days they have been on 
the way. He invites them to his home, treats them 
hospitably, and after supper tells them sweet and pleasant 
tales, "among his words an incident wonderful to the 
highest degree." This wonderful story is none other than a 
distorted version of the Book of Tobit. I have translated 
this in full, and in rhymed prose as a specimen of the 
original : — 

The Stoky of Tobit. 

Here, in the days of the pious of old and the elders of age untold, 
there lived a man upright and true, in all his doings good luck he 
knew. Rich was he and great, his eyes looked straight : Tobiah, the 
son of Ahiah the Danite, he helped the poor, to each gave his mite ; 
whene'er a friendless one died, the shroud he supplied, bore the 
corpse to the grave, nor thought his money to save. The men of the 
place, a sin-ruled race, slandering cried, " These Jewish knaves. O 
King, open our graves ; our bones they burn, into charms to turn, 
health to earn." The king angrily spoke, "I will weighten their 
yoke, and their villainy repay ; all the Jews who from to-day, die 
in this town, to the pit take down, to the pit hurry all, without 
burial. "Who buries a Jew, the hour shall rue ; bitter his pang, on 
the gallows shall hang." Soon a proselyte did die, and no friends 
were by ; but the good Tobiah was nigh, the corpse did lave and dress 
for the grave. Some sinners saw the deed, to the judge the word 
they gave, who Tobiah's death decreed. Forth the saint they draw, 
to hang him as by law. But now they near the tree, lo ! no man 
can see, a blindness falls on all, and Tobiah flies their thrall. Many 
friends his loss do weep, but home he doth creep, God's mercies to 
narrate, and his own surprising fate : " Praise ye the Lord, dear 
friends, for his mercy never ends, and to his servants good intends." 
Fear the king distressed, his heart beat at his breast, new decrees his 
fear expressed. "Whoe'er a Jew shall harm," the king cried in 
alarm, " touching his person or personalty, touches the apple of my 
eye ; let no man do this wrong, or I'll hang him near the throng 
high though his rank and his lineage long." And well he kept his 
word, he punished those who erred ; but on the Jews his mercies 
shone, the while he filled the throne. 

1 0. calls the city M1B and miD ; P. QUID. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 523 

Once lay the saint at rest, and glanced upon the nest of a bird 
within his room. Ah ! cruel was his doom ! Into his eye there went 
the sparrow's excrement. Tobiah's sight was gone ! He had an only 
son whom thus he now addressed, " When business ventures pressed, 
I passed from clime to clime, well I recall the time, when long I 
dwelt in Ind, of wealth full stores to find. But perilous was the 
road, and entrusted I my load with one of honest fame, Peer 
Hazeman his name. And now list, beloved son, go out and hire thee 
one, thy steps forthwith to guide UDto my old friend's side. I know 
bis love's full stream, his trust he will redeem ; when heareth he my 
plight, when seeth he thy sight, then will he do the right." The 
youth found whom he sought, a man by travel taught, the ways of 
Ind he knew ; he knew them through and through, he knew them up 
and down, as a townsman knows his town. He brought him to 
his sire, who straightway did inquire, "Knowest thou an Indian 
spot, a city named Tobot ? " " Full well I know the place, I spent a 
two years' space in various enterprise ; its people all are wise and 
honest men and true." " What must I give to you," asked Tobiah of 
his guest, " to take my son in quest ?" '■ Of pieces pure of gold, full 
fifty must be told." "I'll pay you that with joy; start forth now with 
my boy." A script the son did write which Tobiah did indite, and on 
his son bestow a sign his friend would know. The father kissed his 
son, " In peace," said he, "get gone; may God my life maintain till 
thou art come again." The youth and guide to Toboth hied, and 
reached anon, Peer Hazeman. "Why askest thou my name?" 
Straight the answer came : " Tobiah is my sire, and he doth inquire 
of thy health and thy household's." Then the letter he unfolds. 
The contents Peer espies, every doubt flies, he regards the token 
with no word spoken. " 'Tis the son of my friend, who greeting doth 
send. Is it well with him ? Say." " Well with him alway." " Then 
dwell here awhile, and the hours beguile with the tale* you will tell 
of him I loved so well." " Nay, I must part to soothe my father's 
heart. I am his only trust, return at once I must." Peer Hazeman 
agrees, the lad to release j gives him all his father's loan, and gifts of 
his own, raiment and two slaves. To musical staves, the son doth 
homeward wend. By the shore of the sea, went the lad full of glee, 
and the wind blew a blast, and a fish up did cast. Then hastened the 
guide to open the fish's side, took the liver and the gall, to make evil 
to fall ; the liver to put demons to flight, the gall to restore men's 
sight. The youth begged his friend these specifics to lend, then went 
on his way to where his sick sire lay. Then spake the youth to his 
father the truth. " Send not away the guide without pay." The son 
sought the man, through the city he ran, but the man had dis- 
appeared. Said Tobiah, "Be not afeared, 'twas Elijah the seer, 

524 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

whom God sent here to stand by our side, our needs to provide. " 
He bathed both his eyes with the gall of the prize, and his sight was 
restored by the grace of the Lord. 

Then said he to his son, " Now God his grace has shown, dost thou 
not yearn to do a deed in return ? My niece forthwith wed." " But 
her husbands three are dead, each gave up his life as each made her 
his wife ; to her shame and her sorrow, they survived not the morrow.'' 
" If thou wilt do as I wish, take the liver of the fish and burn it 
in fume at the door of her room, 'twill give the demon his doom." 
At his father's command, with his life in his hand, the youth loved 
the maid and wed her nothing afraid. For long timid hours his 
prayer Tobiah pours ; but the incense was alight, the demon took 
flight, and safe was the night. Long and happily wed, on their lives 
sweetly sped. 

The Paralytic, the Man who Honoured His Father, and 
He who Adored the Crucifix. 

Their entertainer tells Joseph and Enan another story of 
piety connected with the burial of the dead. 

" There lived in the days of old a saintly man whose abode was on 
the way to the graveyard. Every funeral passed his door, and he 
would ever rise and join the procession, and assist those engaged in 
the burial. In his old age his feet were paralysed, and he could not 
leave his bed ; the dead passed his doors, and he sighed that he could 
not rise to display his wonted respect. Then prayed he to the Lord : 
" O Lord, who givest eyes to the blind and feet to the lame, hear me 
from the corner of ray sorrowful bed. Grant that when a pious man 
is borne to his grave, I may be able to rise to my feet." His prayer 
was heard, and whenever a pious man was buried, he rose and prayed 
for his soul. On a day, there died one who had grown old in the 
world's repute, a man of excellent piety, yet the lame man could not 
rise as bis funeral passed.' Next day died a quarrelsome fellow, of ill 
repute, and when his body was carried past the lame man's door, the 
paralytic was able to stand. Every one was amazed, for hitherto the 
lame man's rising or resting had been a gauge of the departed's virtues. 
Two sage men resolved to get to the bottom of the mystery. They 
interviewed the wife of the fellow who had died second. The wife 
confirmed the worst account of him, but added, " He had an old 
father, aged one hundred years, and he honoured and served him. 
Every day he kissed his hand, gave him drink, undressed and dressed 

1 See Jellinek, V., 136 and 206. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 525 

him ; daily he brought ox and lamb bones, from which he drew the 
marrow, and made with it dainty foods." Then the people knew that 
the honouring of his father had atoned for his transgressions. Then 
the two inquisitors went to the house of the pious man, before whom 
the paralytic had been unable to rise. His widow gave him an 
excellent character ; he was gentle and pious ; prayed three times a 
day, and at midnight rose and went to a special chamber to say his 
prayers. No one had ever seen the room but himself, as he ever kept 
the key in his bosom. The two inquisitors opened the door of this 
chamber, and found a small box hidden in the window-sill ; they 
opened the box, and found in it a golden figure, bearing a crucifix. 
Thus the man had been one of those who do the deeds of Zimri, and 
expect the reward of Phineas.'' l 

Table Talk 

They retire to rest, and their sleep is sweet and long. 
By strange and devious ways they continue the journey 
on the morrow. Again they pass the night at the 
house of one of Enan's friends, who welcomes them 
cordially, feeds them bountifully, aDd then tells stories 
and proverbs " from the books of the Arabs." 

A man said to a sage : " Thou braggest of thy wisdom, but it came 
from me." " Yes," replied the sage, " and it forgot its way back." What 
is style ? Be brief and do not repeat yourself. The king once visited 
a nobleman's house, and asked the nobleman's son : " Whose house is 
better, your father's or mine ? " " My father's," said the boy, " while 
the king is in it." A king put on a new robe which did not become him. 
" It is not good to wear,'' said a courtier, " but it is good to put on." 
The king gave him the robe. A bore visited a sick man : " What ails 
thee?" he asked. " Thy presence," said the sufferer. A man of high 
lineage reviled a wise man of lowly birth. "My lineage is a blot on 
me," retorted the sage, " thou art a blot on thy lineage." Diogenes and 
Dives were attacked by robbers. " Woe is me," said Dives, " if they 
recognise me?" "Woe is me," said Diogenes, "if they do not 
recognise me." An Arab's brother died. " Why did he die ? " one 
asked. " Because he lived," was the answer. Which is the best of the 
beasts ? Woman.' Hide thy virtues, as thou hidest thy faults. A dwarf 
brought a complaint to his king. " No one," said the king, " would 

1 See p. 508 above. The author here enters into a powerful denuncia- 
tion of those who are " abstainers from virtue " — who are virtuous 
without and vicious within. 

* Cf . Sen Sira, 22b ; Mishle Chachamim, 22. 

526 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

hurt such a pigmy." "But," retorted the dwarf, "my injurer is smaller 
than I am." The king heard a woman at prayer, " Ck>d," she sail, 
" remove this king from us." " And put a better in his stead," added 
the eavesdropping monarch. Take measures for this Ufa as though thou 
wilt live for ever; prepare for the next world as though thou diest to- 
morrow. Three things weary : a lamp that will not burn, a messenger 
who dawdles, a table spread and waiting. Theu follow a string of 
sayings about threes} Reason rules the body, wisdom is the pilot, 
law is its light. 8 Might is the lion's, burdens are the ox's, wisdom is 
the man's ; spinning the spider's, building the bee's, making stores the 
camel's. In three cases lying is permissible : ia war, in reconciling 
man to man, in appeasing one's wife. Their host concludes his lengthy 
list of sententious remarks thus : — A king had a signet ring on which 
were engraved the words, " Thou hast bored me : rise !" and when a 
guest stayed too long he sho wed the visitor the ring. This was the 
sigoal for the party to retire to rest. 3 

The City op Enan. 

Next day the wayfarers reach Enan's own city, the 
place which he had all along desired Joseph to see. He 
shows Joseph his house ; but he replies, " I crave for food, 
not for sight-seeing." " Surely," said Enan ; " the more 
hurry the less speed." At last the table is spread ; the 
cloth is ragged, the dishes contain unleavened bread, such as. 
there is no pleasure in eating, and there was a dish of herbs 
and vinegar. Then there ensues a long wrangle, displaying 
much medical knowledge, on the physiology of herbs and 
vegetables ; on the eating of flesh, much and fast. Enan 
makes sarcastic remarks on Joseph's rapacious appetite. 
He tells Joseph he must not eat this nor that ; a joint of 
lamb is brought on the table, Enan says the head is bad, 
and the feet, and the flesh and the fat ; so that Joseph has 
no alternative but to eat it all. 4 " I fear that what happened 
to the king will befall thee," said Enan. " Let me feed 

1 Three is a favourite number in Sanskrit collections of this nature. 
8 P. is here better. 

3 This conversation is extremely long, and I have very much shortened 
it. C. and P. vary considerably here. 

4 C. is much longer here than P. 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 527 

first," * said Joseph ; " then you can tell me what happened 
to the king." 

The Princess and the Rose. 

A gardener 2 came to his garden in the winter. It was the month 
of Tebet, and he found some roses in flower. He rejoiced at seeing 
them ; and he picked them, and put them on a precious dish, car- 
ried them to the king, and placed them before him. The king was 
surprised, and the flowers were goodly in his sight ; and he gave the 
gardener one hundred pieces of gold. Then said the king, in his 
heart, " To-day we will make merry, and have a feast." All his servants 
and faithful ministers were invited to rejoice over the joy of the 
roses. And he sent for his only daughter, then with child ; and she 
stretched forth her hand to take a rose, and a serpent that lay in the 
dish leapt at her and stung her, and she died before night. 

Question and Answer. 

But Joseph's appetite was not to be stayed by such tales 
as this. So Enan tells him of the "Lean Fox and the 
Hole " ; but in vain. " Open not thy mouth to Satan," said 
Joseph ; " I fear for my appetite, lest it become smaller ; " 
and goes on eating. 

Now Enan tries another tack : he will question him, and 
put him through his paces. 

"How canst thou sleep," said Enan, " when thou hast eaten every- 
thing, fresh and stale ? As I live, thou shalt not seek thy bed until I 
test thy wisdom— until I prove whether all this provender has entered 
the stomach of a wise man or of a fool." Then follows an extraordinary 
string of anatomical, medical, scientific, and Talmudical questions about 
the optic nerves, the teeth ; why a man lowers his head when thinking 
over things he has never known, but raises his head when thinking 
over what he once knew but has forgotten ; the physiology of the 
digestive organs, the physiology of laughter ; why a boy eats more 
than a man ; why it is harder to ascend than to go down a hill ; 
why snow is white ; why babies have no teeth ; 3 why children's 
first set of teeth falls out ; why saddest tears are saltest ; why sea 

1 This retort is only in P. 

*c., pj; p., pntoa. 

3 C. alone has this. Altogether, the medical conversations are fuller 
in 0. than in P. 

528 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

■water is heavier than fresh ; why hail descends in summer ; why the 
sages said that bastards are mostly clever. To these questions, which 
Enan pours out in a stream, Joseph readily gives answers. But now 
Enan is hoist with his own petard. " I looked at him," continues the 
poet, " and sleep entrapped his eyes, and his eyelids kissed the hides. 
Ah ! I laughed in my heart, now will I talk to him, and puzzle him as 
he has been puzzling me. He shall not sleep, as he would not let me 
sleep. ' My lord,' said I, ' let me now question thee.' ' I am sleepy,' 
said he, ' but ask on.' ' What subject shall I choose ? ' I said. 'Any 
subject,' he replied ; ' of all knowledge I know the half.' " Joseph 
asks him astronomical, musical, logical, arithmetical questions ; to all of 
which Enan replies, " I do not know." " But," protests Joseph, " how 
could you assert that you knew half of every subject when it is clear 
that you know nothing?" "Exactly," said Enan, "for Aristotle 
says: 'He who says, "I do not know," has already attained the half of 
knowledge.'" But he says he knows medicine ; so Joseph proceeds to 
question him. Soon he discovers that Enan is again deceiving him ; 
and he roundly abuses Enan for his duplicity. 

Enan at length is moved to retort. " I wonder at thy learning," says 
Enan, " but more at thy appetite." l Then the lamp goes out, the 
servant falls asleep, and they are left in darkness till the morning. 
Then Joseph demands his breakfast, and goes out to see his ass. The 
ass attempts to bite Joseph, who strikes it, and the ass speaks. " I am 
one of the family of Balaam's ass," 2 says the animal. " But I am not 
Balaam," says Joseph, " to divine that thou hast eaten nothing all 
night." The servant asserts that he fed the ass, but the animal had 
gobbled up everything, his appetite being equal to his owner's. But 
Joseph will not believe this ; and Enan is deeply hurt. " Peace ! " he 
shouts, and his eyes shoot flames, and his nostrils distil smoke ; " Peace, 
or as I live, and my ancestor Asmodaaus, I will seize thee with my 
little finger, and will show thee the city of David." 

Enan Reveals Himself. 

In timid tones I asked him, continues Joseph, "Who is this 
Asmodseus, thy kinsman ? " " Asmodaaus," said Enan, " the great 
prince who, on his wing, bore Solomon from his kingdom to 
a distant strand." "Woe is me," I moaned, "I thought thee 
a friend ; now thou art a demon. Why did'st thou hide thy 
nature ; why did'st thou conceal thy descent ? Why hast 
thou taken me from my home in guile?" "Nay," said Enan, 
"where was thy understanding? I gave thee my name, thou 

1 C. much fuller here. 

2 Thus P. ; C. has, " I am the son of Balaam's ass." 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 529 

shouldst have inverted it." ' Then Enan gives his pedigree : " I am 
Eiian, the Satan, son of Arnan the Demon, son of the Place of Death, 
son of Anger, son of Death's Shadow, son of Terror, son of Tremb- 
ling, son of Destruction, son of Extinction, son of Evil-name, son 
of Mocking, son of Plague, son of Deceit, son of Injury, son of 
Asmodaeus." * Then Enan quiets Joseph's fears, and promises that no 
harm shall befall him. He goes through Enan's city, sees wizards 
and sorcerers, and sinners and fools, all giants. 

Enan's Friend and His Daughter. 

Then Enan introduces his own especial friend : 3 "He is good and 
wiBe," said Enan, " despite his tall stature. He shows his goodness in 
bating the wise and loving fools ; he is generous, for he will give a 
beggar a crust of dry bread, and make him pay for it ; he knows 
medicine, for he can tell that if a man is buried he has either been 
sick or had an accident ; he knows astronomy, for he can tell that it 
is day when the sun shines, and night when the stars appear ; he 
knows arithmetic, for he can tell that one and one make two ; he 
knows mensuration, for he can tell how many handbreadtbs his belly 
measures ; he knows music, for he can tell the difference between the 
barking of a dog and the braying of an ass." " But," said I, continues 
Joseph, " how can you be the friend of such a one ? Accursed is he, 
accursed his master." " Nay," answered Enan, " I love him not ; I 
know his vile nature : 'tis his daughter that binds me to him, for she 
is fair beyond my power to praise." "Yet I warned him against marry- 
ing the daughter of an uneducated man, an am-haaretz." Then follows 
a compilation of passages directed against ignorance. 4 " Ah ! " cries 
Enan, " your warning moves me. My love for her is fled. Thou 
f earest God and lovest me, my friend. What is a friend ? One heart 
in two bodies. Then find me another wife, one who is beautiful and 
and good. Worse than a plague is a bad woman. Listen to what 
once befell me with such a one." 

The Washerwoman who did the Devil's Work. 4 

Once upon a time, in my wanderings to and fro upon the earth, I 
came to a city whose inhabitants dwelt together, happy, prosperous, 
and secure. I made myself well acquainted with the place and people, 
but despite all my efforts, I was unable to entrap a single one. " This 

1 See p. 509 above. 3 P. has a longer chain of descent. 

3 See p. 507 note 1 above. 4 C. considerably fuller here. 

s This story is peculiar to 0. ; P. does not give it. 

530 The Jewish Quarterly Review. 

is no place for me," I said, " I had better return to my own country." 
I left the city, and journeying on came across a river, at whose brink 
I seated myself. Scarcely had I done so, when a woman appeared 
bearing her garments to be washed in the river. She looked at 
me, and asked, " Art thou of the children of men or of demons ? " 
" Well,'' said I, " I have grown up among men, but I was born among 
demons." "But what art thou after here?" "Ah," I replied, "I 
have spent a whole month in yonder city. And what have I found ? 
A city full of friends, enjoying every happiness in common. In vain 
have I tried to mingle a little of wickedness among them." Then the 
woman, with a supercilious air : " If I am to take thee for a specimen, 
I can have a very poor opinion of the whole tribe of demons. You 
seem mighty enough, but you haven't the strength of women. Stop 
here and keep an eye on the wash ; but mind, play me no tricks. I 
will go back to the city and kindle therein fire and fury, and pour 
over it a spirit of mischief, and thou shalt see how I can manage 
things." " Agreed," said I, " I will stay here and await thy coming, 
and see how affairs turn out in thy hands." 

The washerwoman departed, went into the city, called upon one of 
the great families there residing, and requested to see the lady of the 
house. She asked for a washing order, which she promised to execute 
to the most perfect satisfaction. While the housemaid was collecting 
the linen, the washerwoman lifted her eyes to the beautiful face of 
the mistress, and exclaims : " Yes, they are a dreadful lot, the men ; 
they are all alike, a malediction on them! The best of them is not to 
be trusted. They love all women but their own wives." " What 
dost thou mean ? " asked the lady. " Merely this," she answered : 
" Coming hither from my house, whom should I meet but thy husband, 
making love to another woman, and such a hideous creature too ! 
How he could forsake beauty so rare and exquisite as thine for such 
disgusting ugliness, passes my understanding. But do not weep, dear 
lady, don't distress thyself and give way. I know a means by which 
I will bring that husband of thine to his senses, so that thou shalt 
suffer no reproach, and he shall never love any other woman than 
thee. This is what thou must do. When thy husband comes home, 
speak softly and sweetly to him ; let him suspect nothing ; and when 
he has fallen asleep, take a sharp razor and cut off three hairs from 
his beard ; black or white hairs, it matters not. These thou must 
afterwards give me, and with them I will compound such a remedy 
that his eyes shall be darkened in their sockets, so that he will look 
no more upon other lovely women, but cling to thee alone in mighty 
and manifest and enduring love." All this the lady promised, and 
gifts besides for the washerwoman, should her plan prosper. 

Carrying the garments with her, the woman now sought out the 

Joseph Zabara and his " Book of Delight." 531 

lady's husband. With every sign of distress in her voice and manner, 
she told him that she had a frightful secret to divulge to him. She 
knew not if she would have the strength to do so. She would rather 
die first. The husband was all the more eager to know, and would not 
be refused. " Well, then,'' she said, " I have just been to thy house 
where my lady, thy wife, gave me these garments to wash ; and, white 
I was yet standing there, a youth, of handsome mien and nobly 
attired, arrived, and the two withdrew into an adjoining room : so I 
inclined mine ear to listen to their speech, and this is what I over- 
heard : The young man said to thy wife, 'Kill thy husband, and I 
will marry thee.' She, however, declared that she was afraid to do 
such a dreadful deed. ' Oh,' answered he, with a little courage, ' it 
is quite easy. When thy husband is asleep take a sharp razor and cut 
his throat.' " In fierce rage, but suppressing all outward indication of 
it, the husband returned home. Pretending to fall asleep, he watched 
his wife closely ; saw her take a razor to sever the three hairs for the 
washerwoman's spell ; darted up suddenly, wrested the razor from 
her hands, and with it slew his wife on the spot. 

The news spread ; the relations of the wife united to avenge her 
death, and kill the husband. In their turn his relatives resolved to 
aveoge him ; both houses get embroiled, and before the feud was at an 
end two hundred and thirty lives were sacrificed. The city resounded 
with a great cry, the like of which had never been heard. " From 
that day," concluded Enan, "I decided to injure no man more, Tet 
for this very reason I fear to wed an evil woman.'' " Fear not," re- 
turned Joseph, " the girl I recommend is beautiful and good." And 
Enan married her, and loved her. 

Joseph Returns Home to Barcelona. 

"After awhile I said to him," concludes Joseph : " I have 
sojourned long enough in this city, whose ways please me 
not. Ignorance prevails, and poetry is unknown ; the law 
is despised ; the young are set over the old ; they slander 
and are impudent. Let me go home after my many years 
of wandering in a strange land. Fain would I seek the 
place where dwells the great prince, R Sheshet Ben- 
veniste, 1 of whom Wisdom says, Thou art my teacher, and 
Faith, Thou art my friend." " What," said Enan, " what 
qualities brought him to this lofty place of righteousness 

1 Thus P. ; 0. has ntwail J3 TVIW. 

532 The Jewish Quarterly Renew. 

and power ?" " His simplicity and humility, his upright- 
ness and saintliness." 1 

And with this eulogy of the aged Rabbi of Barcelona, 
the poem ends. 

It will be clear from the mode in which I have rendered 
these stories, and also from what has preceded, that I take 
Zabara to be rather a literary curiosity than a poet. Some 
poetical merits he has, but he is more interesting as a 
conteur than as an imaginative writer. The New- Hebrew 
verse was always an exotic, never quite a natural flower ; 
for the labours of the most skilful gardeners failed to accli- 
matise it thoroughly in European soil. Yet his humour, 
his fluent simplicity, his easy mastery over Hebrew, his 
invention, his occasional gleams of fancy, his very artless- 
ness, combine to give his poem some right to the title by 
which he called it — The Book of Delight. 

I. Abrahams. 

1 C. has at the end an additional paragraph beginning JTlT , "tt VSpBTl* 
JlVpJ Hv ntP2D. This passage is quoted from Jer. Shekalim, i7c. OL 
T. B. Atodah Zarah, 20*.